Virtuous Circles (Railtrack major station identities, Lloyd Northover, UK)

A little while ago I wrote about British Railways’ totem signs, which are now highly collectible, as are many railway posters, carriage number plates from London Underground trains, old bus stop flags, and e-tiles (those are the little square tiles with the bus route numbers on – early enamelled ones, especially London ones, are much sought after). These now all fetch good prices at specialist transport auctions.

The problem is you can never tell which bits of transport are going to be collectible in years to come. On the UK railways I have a sneaking suspicion that the station nameplates used by south of London train operator Southern might well become collectible as they are beautifully enamelled and many feature the traditional “Southern” logo too. The Isle of Wight’s Island Line has fitted retro-style totem (or hot-dog sausage-shaped if you really must) signs to its stations, and these might become collectible too, as a later take on an iconic classic.

Please note that the beauty of transport blog cannot give investment advice and should not be relied upon in any way for the purposes of financial planning. Examples of transport memorabilia featured in this article might never achieve collectible status. The value of transport memorabilia can go down as well as up, and it’ll be just my luck if the orange APTIS tickets I threw out the other day turn out to be highly valuable in 40 years’ time. So, disclaimer out of the way…

I suspect that another type of station sign, assuming that any survive, will also become collectible:  those featuring the station identities for Railtrack’s major British railway stations. I only recently realised that Network Rail (Railtrack’s successor as the British rail infrastructure operator and operator of the busiest stations in the country) no longer seems to use Railtrack’s series of rather wonderful station logos for its major stations. They’re still featured on signs around the stations, but no longer feature on paper publicity materials at the stations, and I fear that at some point they will disappear from the station signage, when the next round of replacements come along. So let’s celebrate this lovely, and clever, set of designs while we still can.

It’s fair to say that Railtrack isn’t much lamented. A publicly-quoted private sector company (rather than Network Rail’s status as not-for-dividend company limited by guarantee), Railtrack got itself a reputation for placing the interests of its share price before that of the railway itself. There is more than a little truth in that, but there is a more complex story too, and a full assessment of Railtrack’s failings (and its successes) will probably have to wait for a bit more temporal distance. But one success was its early focus on its major stations. For reasons that have become somewhat cloudy, Railtrack became responsible for operating the busiest British railway stations. At most other stations Railtrack remained the owner but one of the train operators ran the stations on a day-to-day basis, a situation which remains to this day. And as a profit-making private sector company with shareholders to placate and reward with dividends, Railtrack swiftly set about commercialising its major stations, laying the groundwork for the “station as destination” model which is now best seen in Britain at St Pancras International.

As part of that process, Railtrack’s stations were given a visual face lift through new signage, which began to appear from 1999. To design the new major station signage and visual identity, Railtrack had called upon brand communications consultancy Lloyd Northover (check out its website – you’ll recognise a lot of its work). The company was set up in the mid 1970s by designers John David Lloyd and Jim Northover, and worked on many famous brand images (including Hong Kong’s Mass Transit Railway, and the-then British Airports Authority, to name but two transport-related ones), winning numerous international awards along the way.

Lloyd Northover developed a new typeface and set of pictograms to be used on station signage throughout Railtrack’s portfolio of major stations, as well as new and standardised ways of showing the information on the signs. The photo below shows the four-sided suspended information points which became a common sight. Examples are still visible at Network Rail’s major stations, and the typeface and pictograms remain those developed by Lloyd Northover.

Lloyd Northover signage at Waterloo. © Daniel Wright, 2013
Lloyd Northover signage at Waterloo. © Daniel Wright, 2013

The new brand image was quite controversial at the time. For its signage, the nationalised British Rail had used black text on white backgrounds since 1965. Lloyd Northover’s designs for the privatised Railtrack’s new signage instead used white (or sometimes yellow) text on a dark blue background. This was said to be easier to read for partially sighted passengers. But not everyone liked it. Some people said that light text on a dark background was actually worse for partially sighted people (I suspect that actually both light on dark, and dark on light, pose different problems for people with different sorts of partial sight). And some people just didn’t like something which was different to black text on white, which they’d gotten used to…having apparently forgotten that the pre-1965 British Railways totems used white text on dark coloured backgrounds, and that Railtrack’s new signage was in effect a return to that earlier standard.

Meanwhile, Lloyd Northover delivered one extra, rather special, element. As well as the standardised signage, each major station got its own unique identity logo, based on its architecture, its history or the local area. The logos were circular, and appeared on relevant signage around the station and on associated publicity. And they were quite lovely. They were so simple in concept, but so clever, and so beautiful. Each was in a particular colour which was then repeated as accents on the station signage too (in fact, if you look carefully at the photo above, you can see there is a maroon stripe along the bottom of the hanging sign, just above Network Rail’s later “Welcome to Waterloo” banner; Waterloo’s logo was on a maroon background).

Here are eight of the logos from Lloyd Northover co- founder John David Lloyd’s archive website:

Eight of the Railtrack major station identities by Lloyd Northover. As featured on John David Lloyd’s website (here)
  • Gatwick Airport’s G reflects aviation.
  • London Victoria’s logo has a silhouette of the young Queen Victoria (after whom the street on which the station stands was named).
  • London King’s Cross is a visual pun.
  • London Paddington’s P reflects the form of the screens at the end of Brunel’s trainshed roofs at the station.
  • The lion on London Waterloo’s logo used to be outside the station before being moved a bit further down the South Bank to near County Hall.
  • Glasgow Central’s G is based on the typography developed by local boy (not that he was really appreciated at the time) Charles Rennie Mackintosh.
  • Leeds City’s logo features the white rose of the Royal House of York.
  • Edinburgh Waverley’s logo is based on Edinburgh Castle.

Here’s Glasgow Central’s at a larger size, just because I’m a great admirer of Mackintosh’s work, as I’ll explain another time:

Glasgow Central station identity by Lloyd Northover. As featured on John David Lloyd’s website (here)

As well as the eight above, Railtrack eventually operated several another 10 major stations…

London Bridge (the design being based on London Bridge itself):

London Bridge station identity by Lloyd Northover. As featured on John David Lloyd’s website (here)

Charing Cross (the cross from the replica Eleanor Cross outside the station):

Charing Cross station identity by Lloyd Northover. As featured on John David Lloyd’s website (here)

Manchester Piccadilly (based on one of the viaducts near the station, though I don’t know which one for certain, and with a stylised image arguably it’s hard to say for sure):

Manchester Piccadilly station identity by Lloyd Northover. As featured on John David Lloyd’s website (here)

Birmingham New Street (to my shame I spent several years at University there but still can’t work out what the New Street logo is based on):

By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
Birmingham New Street signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
London Euston (the logo recalls the lost Euston Arch which used to stand outside the station):

London Euston station signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
London Euston station signage (again, note the logo’s background and accent on the signage both the same colour). By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
…and London Liverpool Street (the logo is based on the ironwork detailing in the station roof):

London Liverpool Street station signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [GFDL or CC-BY-SA-3.0], via Wikimedia Commons
London Liverpool Street station signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [GFDL or CC-BY-SA-3.0], via Wikimedia Commons
You’ll have noticed a ‘missing’ major station: London St Pancras. Thanks to its role as the designated terminus of High Speed 1 (from the Channel Tunnel to London) it was never operated by Railtrack, remaining operated by its train operator user Midland Mainline, until it was transferred to London & Continental Railways (LCR) for rebuilding as St Pancras International. It never received the Lloyd Northover image. Network Rail agreed the rights to operate the station with LCR in 2001/02 (I still haven’t pinned down the exact date), but the station remains owned by LCR, and has a unique corporate image throughout.

During its time as infrastructure operator, Railtrack occasionally inherited extra stations, which were passed to it from train operator management, on the basis that Railtrack’s commercial division was better placed to maximise value from this real estate. It gained Fenchurch Street (the logo being based on the adjacent Tower of London):

By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
London Fenchurch Street signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
…and London Cannon Street (another play on words, though Cannon Street on which the station stands is apparently a corruption of candle-makers’ street):

By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
London Cannon Street signage. By Sunil060902 (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 or GFDL], via Wikimedia Commons
And I’m pretty sure that Liverpool Lime Street was a later transfer too, though I’m happy to be corrected. Its logo featured the city’s Liver bird and the River Mersey:

Liverpool Lime Street, station sign.
Liverpool Lime Street signage. Via the ‘Share’ button on this Flickr page. © Jonathan Wilcox

As I mentioned, Network Rail doesn’t seem to be using these logos as widely as Railtrack once did (there’s no sign of them on Network Rail’s major station information website pages, for instance, and the signage at the new King’s Cross western concourse omits that station’s logo altogether). Although Network Rail has stuck with the Lloyd Northover signage, I suspect the individual station logos are being phased out, though they remain on many of the signs at the stations for now. If they are indeed being phased out, they will slowly disappear as signage which features them is updated, refreshed or replaced. Those at Gatwick Airport station look certain to disappear sooner rather than later. In an unusual move, responsibility for its operation has passed from Network Rail management to that of train operator Southern – so expect the Lloyd Northover major stations branding to disappear from there before too long, along with the Gatwick Airport station logo.

If these clever pieces of design are being lost from the stations, I for one will miss them. Until, I suspect, some years down the line, an example of Lloyd Northover’s Railtrack major stations identity signage line turns up at auction, station identifier logo and all.

21 thoughts on “Virtuous Circles (Railtrack major station identities, Lloyd Northover, UK)

    1. Yes, they really are little pieces of beauty that don’t have to be there (as evidenced by the fact that they seem to be disappearing) but by being so, bring something special to the stations where they’re found. The sad thing is that there’s no particular reason to get rid of them. They could have been included on the new Western Concourse at King’s Cross, but clearly Network Rail has decided it doesn’t want them. Oh well – make the most of them while they last!

    1. Having spent years in Birmingham (studying transport, as it happens) I can’t say I’ll miss the old concourse, but I will miss the New Street station identity pictograms if they aren’t included in the new concourse (which I might cover as a topic one day as well). Not sure if you’re local, but if you are, perhaps you could check out the new concourse at some point and let us all know. If the station identity pictogram is missing from the signage, we’ll know it’s Network Rail policy to phase them out.

  1. I believe there are a few replacement signs at Leeds which haven’t got the logo on them, which is a shame. Plus some of the signage is in a different, non-Brunel font which I imagine the regular passenger won’t even notice but it jarrs every time I see it.

    Oh and apologies for being a pedant but you mention Leeds Central but Leeds Central was closed in 1967, I believe you mean Leeds City? The original signs within the station had Leeds City but these were phased out in later years for just “Leeds”. I took a photo of a trolley point with with “Leeds City”present and uploaded it to the Wikipedia page.

    And your blogs have kept me captivated for hours now, they are absolutely ace!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s